Showing posts with label Beethoven. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Beethoven. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Thoughts on Antagonists: Don Pizarro



Guys, the Zurich 2004 Fidelio with Kaufmann, Nylund and Polgar is now on YouTube in HD, with English subtitles. If you haven't seen it, do. It's worth it for Kaufmann's devastated Florestan alone.

Today's blog post will be, if you haven't already guessed, Fidelio-centric. I've finally, after six months of studying, grumping, procrastinating and generally being lazy, tackled the issue of Don Pizarro.

Pizarro is, by everyone's account and agreement, a cardboard villain. He mustasch-twirls his way through the first act, more gloating in his evil than actually acting it out. He yells at Rocco for letting the prisoners into the garden, and threatens the captain of the guard with dismemberment, but overall, in the first act, Pizarro does not come off as particularly menacing. Many critics have censured Beethoven for this, but the problem is not so much his fault as it is his librettists'.

Pizarro is more malevolent in Act 2, when he tries to murder Florestan and revels in his victory over his enemy. This is where we see how sadistic Pizarro is: here is a man that he has systematically broken over two years, who is about to die anyway from sickness and starvation, and Pizarro gloats over him. We see the end result of his evil in Florestan, who is supposed to be so weak he can hardly move, in chains, and semi-crazy from solitary confinement and long sickness. Listen closely to his aria and you hear the subtext that Florestan has been so ill-treated for so long that he has absolutely no hope of ever regaining earthly freedom. His vision of Leonore is not as a mortal woman, but as angel coming to take him away to heaven. So we see that Pizarro has not been passive about this prisoner. He has taken measures to degrade him to this point, and (as Rocco tells Leonore) has recently ordered him to be slowly starved to death.

The disconnect comes from not making Pizarro himself seem particularly villainous. The menace has to be brought by the singer portraying him. In the hands of a good singing-actor (Walter Berry and Alfred Muff, above, spring to mind) Pizarro can be terrifying. But his evil is more implied than seen.

So how does that translate to the novel that I'm working on?

In fiction, it's essential to have a villain that is a worthy match for the protagonist. Think Harry vs. Voldemort, Valjean vs. Javert, Scarlett O'Hara vs. well, everybody. Leonore is the main protagonist (though Florestan shares the story, his journey is psychological and essentially passive). She smart, strong, brave, and ballsy, and it has been causing me a world of hurt to create a Pizarro that is a worthy match for her. My Pizarro is, at the moment, more of a "phantom menace" to quote one of the more unfortunate Star Wars films: he's there, but they don't clash as much as they should.

So my goal for this month is to write a handful of small scenes to be inserted throughout the text, between Pizarro and Fidelio. I have a great clash between Pizarro and Leonore-as-herself (if I do say so myself), but we see in the opera that Pizarro doesn't like Fidelio much: in the garden scene in Act 1, he attacks her as well as Rocco for letting the prisoners out, snarling that she's a "menial servant". Clue.

I've got my work cut out for me, but I've brainstormed the ideas, and now must bring them to life. And then figure out where in the narrative to put them. Wish me luck.

Tuesday, October 30, 2012

Deutsche Oper 100th Anniversary Gala: a recap

And only a week and a half late. Sorry about that, but things have been incredibly hectic over here, and then for some reason I lost all blogging motivation I'd had, and that was that. But here is my recap, for what it is worth.

Guys, German audiences can be mean. The poor woman who hosted the evening, Tita von Hardenberg, kept getting heckled like you wouldn't believe. Don't come between the Berlin audience and their opera, baby, was the message. I thought she handled herself very well, considering the shouting that started whenever she came onstage to interview one of the conductors (Donald Runnicles, Alberto Zedda and Jesus Lopez Cobos) or the management of the opera. Several of the managers were loudly booed, though I'm not sure which ones, as everyone was talking too fast and in German. There was a nice video trailer about the history of the opera house itself: long story short, the perfectly lovely building got bombed out during the war, and instead of restoring it, they had to raze it to the ground and build a perfectly ugly modern monstrosity in its place. The highlight was Christa Ludwig saying something snarky about the "rocket man" sculpture they have out front (again, my German wasn't up to catching exactly what she said, but I get that it wasn't flattering). The audience whooped and laughed and applauded her for it. That was fun.

But the music is what we all care about, and so here is what I wrote down in my journal the night of the performance. It's going to be piecemeal, but it's better than nothing:

The Gala itself was great, although they were losing Florestan's left and right: first Jonas Kaufmann withdrew, and then his sub got sick, and then the sub's sub got sick, and so it was announced right before intermission that the part of Florestan would be sung by a man named MacAllister. There was general disbelief in the audience, as you can imagine. I will say that he did a fine job with the role, despite having had only a few hours' notice.

Heidi Melton (who was the mastermind behind my being able to attend, for which I am forever grateful) opened the concert with Wagner's "Dich, teure Halle". She was fabulous. For some reason, I'd expected the aria to be solemn, considering the character of Elisabeth, but it was loud and jaunty and gorgeous, and definitely going on my iPod. Melton wore a fabulous, sparkly blue dress, brand new that day: the airline had lost her luggage and her gala gowns, and so emergency shopping was done. You can read all about it on her Twitter page.

We were subjected treated to a world premier of an overture by Hans Werner Henze, who died just this week, thus making me feel a little bad that I thought his Ouverture zu einem Theater was a cacophonous mess. It was just, well, extremely modern, and I'm not quite there yet in my musical tastes. It was quickly followed by Rossini's Semiramide overture, which was a nice palate cleanser.

Afterwards, Vittorio "There's Not A Tenor in the World Who Can Compete With Me" Grigolo came on to sing and (Heaven help us all) act out Romeo's aria Ah! leve-toi, soleil! from Gouno's Romeo and Juliet. Yay. He has a good voice, I'll give him that, but the arrogance involved was (and is) extremely off-putting. And he kept coming back onstage to bow, which was a trifle obnoxious, as we were keen on getting on with the program.

Lastly, we were treated to the Falstaff finale, Tutto nel mondo e burda, which was funny and fun and loud and jolly. And then there was intermission. Thirty minutes worth of music took over an hour to hear, because each and every single piece was preceded and followed by interviews and film clips. It was an extremely disgruntled audience that hit the wine buffet, let me tell you.

Intermission, in which several women told me they liked my dress, everyone got a little hammered, and the German glitterati swept around sparkling like teen vampires at high noon. Seriously, I'm sure there were millionaires and actors and artists and assorted German celebrities there, and believe me when I tell you that I didn't recognize a single one of them. This is one of the advantages of not watching TV.

After the intermission, we all came back for a mercifully uninterrupted Act 2 of Fidelio. It should surprise no one that I am extremely picky about my Fidelios, to the point of being a bore. The fact that we were on our fourth Florestan of the night worried me. I needn't have worried, for our Leonore was Anja Kampe, and she was phenomenal. She carried the whole evening. She made me cry. Her Lenore was scared, but overjoyed to find her Florestan, and hardly ever stopped smiling. She was the only one of the singers to speak, and used the (now rare) line where she tells Florestan to have faith right before Pizarro attacks. Hers is the best Leonore I've ever seen, and I've seen every performance of Fidelio released on DVD and YouTube. Oh, she was a freaking rockstar!

Rocco was sung by Matti Salminen, who I'm given to understand is a baritone of some renown (don't laugh at me if he's extremely famous; I've only just begun to discover Wagnerian baritones) and Bastiaan Everink's Don Pizarro was virile, elegant, and scary as hell. Everink was a young guy, too; I'd have really loved to see him opposite Kaufmann, to see what it would be like to have two relatively young men at each other's throats. Alas, it was not to be.

Fernando, Jacquino and Marzelline were sung by Markus Bruek, Burkhard Ulrich and Martina Welschenbach respectively, and they were all very good. The finale was a miracle of sound and light and beauty, but frankly, if it isn't, something's wrong. The thing that I learned about Fidelio that night was the way that Leonore and Marzelline's vocal lines sort of play off each other in the finale, melding into a gorgeous whole. Again, don't laugh: there's only so much that you can get from a digital recording. Seeing Fidelio live was a real experience for me, because it taught me so much about the music that I couldn't get from a recording. It was stunning, beautiful, fabulous-and now I'm done unloading superlatives and will only say that it went by too fast and I wanted them to do it again when they were finished.

After the gala was a big reception, where they effectively killed the mood brought on by Beethoven by having a rock band perform in the lobby. It was a good band, really, but I was on a Fidelio high, so after wandering around for a bit and eating some of the Deutsche Oper-shaped cake (pictured above), I collected my coat and flats* from the coat check and left. I had wanted to thank Heidi Melton in person for the ticket, and fall at Anja Kampe's feet in general adoring veneration, but neither of them appeared. Unfortunately, I dropped and broke my camera, so the one photo above is the only one I have. Le sigh.

All in all, it was a great night and I'm glad I went.

*I made an elderly lady in the subway laugh by changing out of my heels into my ballet flats: I can't walk well in heels in general, and there was no way I was riding home in them if I didn't have to.

Wednesday, October 17, 2012

When I get really, really good news


I will be attending the Deutsche Oper 100th Anniversary Gala this Saturday, thanks to the ever-fabulous Heidi Melton and her generosity to this opera fan.

The program includes a heady cocktail of Wagner, Rossini, Verdi, and (most importantly for your truly) the entire second act of Beethoven's Fidelio. I may just end up crying like a little girl.

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

The house where Beethoven composed "Fidelio"


I am in Vienna for a week. Naturally, I am doing Very Important Things. Like visiting all the places where my favorite composers lived.

It's a deceptively simple building, and not very well publicized: the only way I realized that this is what I was looking for was the "Beethoven Shop" sign. Otherwise it was unmarked. But if you climbed up four flights of stairs, past the apartments were people actually live (!!!!!), you will find Beethoven's lovely, airy apartment.




It has a good view of the Vienna University, which I don't think was there in his day:

Did I have a moment? Yes, I did. :-)

Saturday, August 11, 2012

Flavors of Beethoven


Occasionally I get awesome emails from friends that contain beauties like the above. "Saw this and thought of you" is generally the accompanying statement. :-)

Saturday, July 21, 2012

The Strange Case of the Composer and his Judge

I've gotten lucky this summer with the books I've been reading: they're almost uniformly fascinating, sink-your-teeth-into-them stories with strong plots, strong characterization, and darn fine storytelling. I can't tell you how much I value that. One of the most recent books I read was the thoroughly enjoyable The Strange Case of the Composer and his Judge, by Patricia Duncker.

This book tells the story of a French juge d'instruction, Dominique Carpentier, who specializes in gathering information on fanatical religious sects. When one of these cults, known only as the Faith, commits mass suicide, the Judge (as she is known throughout the story) is pitted against the enigmatic Composer, Friedrich Grosz, who is connected to every single one of the dead. Her quest to find out what he knows about the sect takes her all over Europe, from sunny Provence to England to the Lubeck Festival in Germany. And through it all runs music.

The entire book is a masterpiece of sound and color, light and darkness, heat and cold. Duncker weaves a vivid picture of sweltering summer days spent eating lunch on the terrace of a Provencal vineyard, shivering winter days wandering from one German bookbinder to another, and two magical nights at the opera. Because that's the thing: the Composer is world-famous, one of the heads of the international music scene. He's very clearly modeled on Herbert von Karajan (whom I pictured throughout) or Daniel Barenboim. And he is not afraid of the Judge, or angry at her for her pursuit of his knowledge: rather, he loves her for it. And he uses what he knows best to attract her: music.

The Judge has no use for classical music, but still attends two operas: the Lubeck Festival's Tristan and a concert performance of Fidelio at Royal Albert Hall. The author clearly has a fine grasp of opera, clearly enjoys it herself. As her Composer says of Tristan, when learning that the Judge has never been to an opera before,

"Madame Carpentier, you are a very corageous woman. I have conducted this opera many, many times in the course of my professional life. Yet each time I find something new, fresh and miraculous in the score. So, even for an old hand like myself, the familiar remains strange, uncharted, even obscure. Let me advise you how to listen. Do not rationalize. I know that you are a very rational person. A Judge must be so, to sift the evidence. But put that part of yourself aside. Do not assess things or try to calculate. Or really even try to listen. Let go of everything...Yes, let go. And give the music time to speak to you. ...If you are not an aficionado you will be harder to persuade. We will give you our best. Our very best"

She then goes on to describe a Tristan so sensual as to be almost erotic. The Fidelio scene is much the same. Duncker uses words in a way that you really do hear the music, even if you've never actually listened to either opera before. The writing is sensuous, elegant, and the story interesting. The characterization is strong, from the cool Judge to the passionate Composer to the overbearing chief of police and the sylph-like daughter of the deceased.

I give it five stars, and will be reading it again.

Tuesday, April 3, 2012

Berlin makes me laugh so hard sometimes.

Truly, this city has some of the most awesome signage. I've taken to carrying my camera around lately, because beauties like the following just seem to appear out of nowhere.

Basic Translation: "Mozart...or Beethoven? Which composer wrote only one opera but nine symphonies? This, and two hundred other questions are in your daily copy of Die Zeit [a local newspaper]."


Note: this is the sign for the Wotan Apotheke. Apparently, their products are fit for the Norse gods. I wonder if they play Wagner inside? I would.

Monday, January 23, 2012

Great composers reimagined

Continuing in the art vein I've been in lately, let's see how people are re-imagining the Great Composers (please note, the names are links to the artist's sites):

Beethoven:

Mozart:

Wagner:

Verdi:

I promise to make a real, substantial post soon (I've got one brewing on Don Carlo), but for now, enjoy!

Monday, November 14, 2011

Berlin: Tiergarten

I went exploring in Tiergarten, Berlin's answer to Central and Golden Gate Parks, this past weekend. It was beautiful, all fall foliage and black-water lakes (not a little creepy, but atmospheric). I only got through half the park, walking for about an hour, but I stumbled upon this lovely memorial to three great German composers: Haydn, Mozart, and my own dear Beethoven:



The memorial, a discreet sign explained in four languages, was constructed sometime in the 1850s. It was damaged during the First and Second World Wars (Mozart bears a few bullet holes, as does Haydn's pedestal), and parts of it went missing. But, in true German spirit, the whole thing was restored in the decades following the cease-fire. They replaced the gilding and the missing swan's necks, made a new pedestal out of marble from the original quarry, and made an elegant little garden out of the area. It looks like it would be a nice place to have summer concerts.

If you look closely, you can see what looks like little black spots all over Herr von Beethoven's face. They're actually some sort of insect. Of the three composers honored, Beethoven was the least spotty.